Question: My ex and I have been working on getting back together for the last month. Things were going really great up until about a week ago. It started when she said something and I said her recollections of what happened are not really accurate memories of the relationship as a whole. She seems to only remember the problems we had and gets angry when I bring up the good times we had together. We have known each other for almost 4 years and had some really great times, it’s hard to forget stuff that you want to remember and keep with you.
Now she says she thinks it’s best if we stop trying to get back together because it will never work between us. I worry that if I do not try to get her back and more time passes, she’ll move further and further away from me. I’d really appreciate your insights on my situation.
Yangki’s Answer: I’m sure hearing that most couples attempting to get back together at some point hit a wall isn’t much of a comfort, but I thought I’d say it anyway, just in case it helps – a little.
If she doesn’t want to talk about the old relationship, just don’t bring it up. I understand you don’t want to forget the good memories, but if this is the end result, it doesn’t make sense to keep bringing it up. If it means that much to you to keep the good memories alive, keep a journal, scrapbook or something. May be at some point in the future, she will be more open to sharing these memories with you
My experience reconciling couples tells me this is not the reason she suddenly decided after weeks of trying to get back together that things will not work out. It seems to me that the fight reminded her that even if you’ve been trying to get back together there are still some unresolved issues that are not allowing the reconciliation process to move forward.
Of course talking about the old relationship would help identify and resolve those unresolved issues but that doesn’t seem like an option since she does not want to talk about the past. Pushing it will only make things worse.
My advice is for you to set up a meeting to talk. Ask her what if anything needs to be changed or improved to make this work. Try as much as possible not to focus on these as “problems” but rather as challenges to be solved.
Why is this important?
When we hear the word “problem”, we mostly think of a “difficult thing/situation”. Something that’s cumbersome, stressuful and even depressing. “Challenge” sounds more like an “invitation to step up and do something about it”. It also sounds much more manageable, positive and hopeful than dealing with a problem. Of course this doesn’t really change what needs to be changed or improved, but it can make a huge difference in attitude and energy.
I wouldn’t worry too much about the more time passes the further away she’ll move from you. If she doesn’t feel like it’ll work, it doesn’t matter how much time passes she will still not want to get back together. For now, give your relationship a decent chance by keeping your focus on why she thinks it’ll not work and showing her that it can. The rest will take care of itself.