Tuesday September 2nd 2014

How To Fight For Your Relationship

ex confused feelingsLately, I’m getting more and more emails from men and women who say they’ve managed to move things forward to a point where they are in regular contact with their ex, and things even seem to be heading towards getting back together. But for some unknown reason, their ex is still confused about how they feel and what they want. Many of the emails are asking me whether in such a situation one ought to be trying to get back together with their ex or just give up. One person asked me if it’s even possible to fight for the relationship and at the same time allow it to happen naturally.

When it comes to relationships, there is having a relationship with someone and there is struggling to hold on to a relationship you want.

What’s the difference?

If you take an object and wrap your hands around it tightly, what you are doing is communicating a desire to possess what you’re holding on to. The (this is mine) energy going into holding tightly gives away the need to control. It also gives away fear of losing what you have in your hand. Though the fear can be disguised as “I love him/her very much“, the reactions are not – anxiety, worrying, over-analyzing, neediness and clinging.

But if you open your hand palm up with the object resting on it, you are not holding on to it possessively and you are not controlling it in anyway. You are allowing it to rest on your palm without any effort on trying to hold it. Because there is no fear involved, there is no anxiety, worrying, over-analyzing and clinging.

I would make the same distinction between “struggling to hold on to a relationship” and  “having a relationship with someone”.

The energy that goes into “struggling to hold on to a relationship” is one of possessiveness, control, aggression and sometimes even hostility. And you wonder why despite your trying so hard to make the relationship work, make the other person feel loved and/or manipulate (try to make them jealous, using guilt or ultimatums), it always backfires on you.

The energy that goes into “having a relationship with someone” on the other hand is one of openness, friendliness, generosity and being willing to let go if you need to, which is what an open palm symbolizes.

So when you say, “I love him/her so much and I’m willing to do anything to fight for our relationship“, ask yourself if your palm is wrapped so tightly around the object of your desire or if the object of your desire is resting on an open palm.

If you are with someone who is struggling with his or her feelings for you, on one hand seems to want to be with you and on the other hand acts like they want out, it’s because you are holding on too tightly. Open your palm with the spirit of openness, friendliness and generosity — and be willing to let go if you need to.

But here is the tricky part: Just telling someone you are not going to hold on tightly and are letting them go isn’t going to convince them that you are no longer going to be clingy, needy, controlling or possessive. In fact it will probably backfire. They may think you are breaking up with them (but not directly) and may rush to end the relationship before you end it.

The best way to show that you are indeed letting go your tight grip and struggling energy, is to walk the walk with the spirit of openness, friendliness and generosity. That is love with all your heart, but be willing to let go.

Readers' Questions and The Love Doctor's Answers...

46 Responses to “How To Fight For Your Relationship”

  1. Erica says:

    Yangki, my situation is a little different in that my ex broke up with me but he is the one who has instituted the no contact rule. He doesn’t want any form of contact and has unfriended me on FB, blocked msn and will not pick up his phone when I call. We were very close, and I don’t understand how things could go from the best we’ve ever been as a couple to not talking to each other at all. He did say when we broke up that he still loved me but does not want to be in a relationship. So I think he’s distancing because he does not want to face his feelings, right?

  2. There’s two ways to look at it…

    1) If when he was breaking up with you he said he didn’t want any contact at all, then it is possible that he is using no contact to distance from his feelings for you and move on with his life.

    2) If he decided to do no contact because you overwhelmed him — pleading, begging, and acting in ways that were not in your best interest, then his decision to use go NC is because he does not want to deal with the drama that follows most break-ups.

  3. Ed says:

    We were together for 4 wonderful months then from out of the blue she said she needed to be alone, that things had moved too fast and she needed time to evaluate how she really feels about me. We still hang out and she says someday we might get back together. Does this somehow mean she regrets breaking up with me or does she just want to be friends. Help!

  4. I think it means just that… things moved too quickly, she wasn’t sure if it’s what she wants and pulled back so she can get a better perspective of the relationship. It also means that you still have a chance to prove to her that you’re what/who she’s looking for. How you go about proving to her that you are what/who she’s looking for will determine whether you get back together, become “just friends” or go your separate ways.

  5. Ed says:

    But don’t you think that’s having her cake and eating it too?

  6. May be, may be not. But what is your alternative? 1) Give up now and walk away, 2) pressure her to make a decision she’s not ready to make?

    I can guarantee that the decision she’ll make under pressure is not going to be in your favour. If she has enough “doubts” to break-up with you, chances are, there are some needs, wants, desires etc that she feels you/the relationship are not meeting. You force her to make a decision and she’ll make it based on 4 months with you. 4 months is a very short time for someone to be able to make a full and accurate evaluation of what you offer/can offer to a relationship. I’m sure in your mind you too know that you have a lot more to offer, there just wasn’t enough time to show it all…

    Take advantage of the opportunity you have RIGHT NOW instead of worrying about what might or might not happen. Right NOW is all you can work with. You do things RIGHT now, and the future will work out right too.

  7. ed says:

    The more I think about it, the more I see that I’m worried about what I can’t control. I love this woman very much and have no intentions of walking away yet. Christine, thank you for helping me see things differently.

  8. Bella says:

    I think that if somebody can’t make up his mind, he is definitely not worth your time. My ex was went back and forth for weeks. I got fed up waiting for him to make up his mind and finally told him to let me go. I have not spoken to him since and he has not contacted me. Don’t waste your time on someone who can’t make up their mind.

  9. This is exactly the kind of attitude I’m talking about. My guess is that when you told him to let you go, you hoped 1) he’d decide he wanted to be with you or 2) you would finally be able to move on.

    But seems none of that happened. In fact it seems things have backfired on you: 1) he let you go and 2) here you are still reading articles about how your ex feels. If you had indeed moved you’d be reading articles about “new love” not wasting your time reading about how your ex feels.

    Any time you try to pressure, control or manipulate how someone else feels about you, you will be the one who ends up frustrated, disappointed, hurt, angry or stuck.

  10. Mike says:

    I sadly put pressure on my ex-girlfriend to get back into a relationship with me. I was not in the right emotional space and did a lot of begging, crying, sent 100?s of text messages, showed up at her home and work. For the three weeks I was a total jerkass, she avoided me and would not respond to my texts. I asked a mutual friend to talk to her and she told him she still loves me but is afraid of me. I’m now doing no contact so she can look at me in the same loving way after all that I’ve put her through. Do you think I can regain her love for me if I am able to give her the space she wants? I want her back and can’t see myself with anyone else.

  11. I don’t think you are helping yourself at all. Swinging from one extreme to the other does not really say you are in a healthy emotional space. In any case, “No Contact” in itself is a form of pressure.

    I think you’ll find my article: Win Your Ex Back With Pressure-Free Contact helpful. She may be afraid of you right now and may not want contact, but you have to start somewhere, somehow. The “No Contact” show down isn’t going to help. With no communication, nothing will happen.

  12. Cjay says:

    I don’t know if this applies to an ex who breaks up with you because she’s in her early 40′s and really desperate for you to make a decision about the future right away. 2 years later she tells you she’s still interested in you and wants another shot. If you still have feelings for her, do you give her another chance?

  13. Depends on if you are now ready to make a decision. If you are not, the two of you will have the same problems and she’ll break-up with you again when she finds out you are still not ready. She probably wants to settle down (and may be have a family) because she sees her time to have a family is running out. This is just my guess. If you are not ready to honour her biological clock, may be not right now but in the near future, it’s best not to give her false hope. She might blame you for the rest of her life…

  14. Insanelyinlove says:

    After 1 month of NC and 1 month of limited contact, I successfully got my ex back. We had been broken up for over 6 months. Things were good for about a month but then they started going straight down hill again. She says we just can’t be together and has started dating other guys. But at the same time she says she loves me and cries that we can’t be together. She says it makes her sad. I also found out that when we broke up the first time she went back to her ex and still hang out with him the month we were back together. I still love her very much and want her back but not sure if there is still anything left to save in this relationship.

  15. There is so much going on in your situation, that I had to treat it as a separate question worthy of it’s own post. The response to your question is here: We Got Back Together and Now Broken Up Again.

  16. Luanda says:

    I like your advice. I have been hoping to get my ex back since we broke up over a year ago. We were in no contact for 2 months, then I contacted him and we started seeing each other but not dating. He has a new gf and they have been together for 7 months. He has introduced her to his parents and they are planning to move in together but we still hang out. He tells me he loves me and may be someday we will be together again. He has said many times he wishes I had not cut him off because he thought I did not love him anymore. I’ve told him I loved him then and still love him very much. Do you think he is confused about his feelings for both of us?

  17. It is possible he is confused, but if he is getting serious with the other woman, he could be telling you all those things because he thinks that’s what you want to hear, especially if “hanging out together” means you are sleeping with him. He may be holding you in place, until he eventually decides to drop you.

    You should be particularly concerned if he met the new woman after you had started seeing each other again, if he never introduced you to his parents or asked you to move in with him. It says this new relationship means a lot more to him than the one the two of you had.

  18. Wen_dreamer says:

    My ex says he likes me but he’s confused about whether he wants me as a friend with benefits or girlfriend. I want more than anything for us to be girlfriend and boyfriend again, but I don’t know what to do. We have already had some time apart.

  19. Have you asked him what he means by “be friends”? Does it include “and see what happens?” If it does, don’t get all upset about it. Take it as just “space” and opportunity to show him that things can work again. If not, then you have to decide if you can manage that at the moment.

    If you still have hopes of getting back together and he’s completely over you, you may find it hard to transition from lover to friend right away and may need some time apart to heal. But be open and let him know how you feel — that’s what true friendship is about.

  20. Calvin says:

    I am very impressed by the advice and wisdom on this site. I’m a 61 year-old man and you are really never too old to learn. Thanks for sharing all this important information – it does make a difference to a lot of us out here.

  21. Thank you, Calvin. It means a lot coming from a 61 year-old man… (:

  22. Namaste_peace says:

    Now you’ve been trapped by love
    Someone takes your heart and then she says goodbye
    So you say that you’ll never love another
    Tired of playing games and that’s the reason why

  23. You say you’re going through changes
    Every day it seems your life is up and down
    And you say that you’re looking for an answer
    Everywhere you look it seems YOU can’t be found

    Like searchin’ tryin’ to find the rainbow
    No one’s ever found it, yet it’s told to be
    But if you’re lookin’ for a …(:
    Everything you need, you can find right here with me

  24. Namaste_peace says:

    Ha ha ha, I’m not looking for a lover. But this is freaking weird! I was sending the words to the universe with no idea anyone would respond or even know the lyrics. I’ve been playing this song since she left me.

    She was 19, I was 21, this was our song. After college we went our separate ways then I found her on Facebook, started communication found out were both single again, electricity first date, 6 months later moved in together, best time of our entire lives, lasted 3 year 2 months, she says she wasn’t happy and moved out. I’ve cried, begged and poured my heart out her but she says made a mistake starting a relationship with me before completely ending it with her ex and hurt both of us by not being honest with herself and with me. The last thing she wants is to hurt me or lose me.

    We found each other again after 28 years and she is still as beautiful to me at 47 as she was at 19. She is my soulmate, Yangki. She has my heart, but I don’t want it back, I just want her. Please help me get her back. I value your advice and would really like to hear from you.

  25. But if you’re lookin’ for….. a Love Coach. Silly!

    You say she’s special to you, I believe you! I know the pain in those lyrics so well… someone sang it to me. I don’t think it’s coincidence at all. I’d love to talk to you about your situation by phone. NO charge. Please respond to the email I sent you with contact info and day/time. May be I can be of some help getting her back.

  26. Crystal says:

    My ex broke up with me but after 3 weeks of no contact he came back and told me he’s in love with me but still not sure if he wants a relationship. I feel as if I’m getting mixed signals. Saying you love someone and not want to be with them is cruel.

  27. You may have heard the saying: “The heart says “yes”, but the mind says “no” — and vice versa.

    Loving someone and wanting to be in a relationship with that person are two different things. We don’t have a choice as to who our hearts choose to love, but we do have a choice on who our heads choose to have a relationship with. So while your ex’s heart may still love you, he has evaluated the relationship and decided it’s not what he wants at this point in time. There are several reasons why someone will not want to be in a relationship even if he still obviously loves his ex.

  28. CrushedAnn says:

    My ex and I have been slowly getting closer. We hang out alone and with friends every weekend. Last weekend, someone made that we obviously love each other why not get back together and he said, “funny that you say that because I never loved K.” he didn’t say he was joking until a couple of friends continued questioning him about it. Later, when we were alone, I asked him if he meant what he said about never loving me and he said he already said he was joking and didn’t want to talk about it. My question is, do you think if someone says they never loved you and then says they were joking that they meant it?

  29. I don’t know why your ex said that or whether he meant it. Regardless, whether he meant it or not, it’s not something a current partner or ex wants to hear, and if you really care about that person’s feelings you don’t say that to them and of all places in the presence of other friends.

    That said, he could have perceived the comment “obviously love each other why not get back together” as “pressure to get back together” and defensively reacted without thinking about what he was saying. Or it could have just been one of those “moments of truth”. I don’t know for sure.

    What bothers me is his reaction when the two of you were alone together. Someone who didn’t mean it and was just joking would have done everything to convince you he indeed was joking — apologized, begged for forgiveness, told you he loved you then and still loves you etc. Instead he just said he didn’t want to talk about it. To me, that says a lot about your relationship!

  30. CrushedAnn says:

    We have had an on and off relationship for the last 3 years. When things are good they are really good and then he starts to distance himself and eventually wants his space. I know I contributed to this because I kept putting pressure for the relationship and he would shut down. I love my ex very much, always have but at times I wish I had never laid eyes on him! I just don’t know what to do.

  31. Chayna says:

    I’m confused. My ex and I broke up in September and 2 weeks later he was dating again. After less than a month he broke up with her but then got back together after a few weeks. When they were broken up he started texting me and we sometimes talk over the phone. I know he still loves me but I’m not sure if he’s just checking in on me – or if it’s more for him. I tried the no contact rule and I was doing great until he started texting me. I don’t know what to do. Should I leave him alone and make him miss me or should I continue contact with him?

  32. It’s up to you if you want to leave him alone/move on or try to get him back. In my opinion, decisions about your life and heart should not be outsourced. To help you make your OWN decision, here are some questions you should ask yourself…

    1) How do you feel that he broke up with the other woman and got back with her, but didn’t do the same with you?
    2) How important are you to him… be honest with yourself. Is he going to miss you when he is already with someone else?
    3) Are you choosing to move on because you feel frustrated or because this is what you really want to do?

    A decision that is true to who you are and how you truly feel, is the RIGHT decision — at the time.

  33. Evelina says:

    I’m a little confused. My ex texts me 1-2 times a week and says he still cares a lot about me and he trusts me. I asked him if he wants to get back and he said may be someday. He says we need a little time apart to work on our respective issues, but then why does he still contact me? I’m wrecking my mind here because I don’t know what he wants. I want him back but how will it happen when we are still in contact?

  34. He wants both of you to work on your issues so that you have a better relationship.

    I think that “time apart” means different things for both of you. In your mind time apart means “no contact”, and in his mind “time apart” means some distance from trying to make the relationship work. In my opinion his is a more mature approach because he is not just thinking of himself, he is also thinking about what’s good for the relationship. The worst thing that can happen to a relationship is that two people cut off contact with the intention of creating a better relationship, only to regroup and there is no relationship.

    By getting all worked up over something completely healthy, you may end up losing him completely. Be glad that your ex still cares about you. So many people would give anything for what you have.

  35. jeanette says:

    My ex broke up with me 3 weeks ago because she feels she has lost the emotional connection and it feels like we are roommates. We own our home together and when I asked her about living arrangements she cried saying she wasn’t ready for me to leave let. She said she needs time to find herself but still wants to hang out with me. When we do hang out it is not in a girlfriend way. I’m concerned about us living together. In your new E-Book on page 196 you say “Going out every day or every other day in the initial stages is probably not a very good idea”

  36. That’s right. It should reflect the stage you are in your efforts to get back together.

    You own a home together, so it’s not like you can push her out. At least not without causing more damage to your chances. You have to work with your circumstances and make the best of it.

    Since you hang out, I assume you get along well. So talk to her… tell her you don’t think that it’s a good idea for you to hangout every night when you are not a couple.

    It’s up to you to set the pace if you want to have a chance of making it work. Sometimes that means giving up what feels good right now for what’s right in the long term. That’s covered in pages 357 – 364.

    Things take time, but you can still make it work if you do it systematically and strategically. Don’t rush anything out of panic or frustration.

  37. Alisa says:

    Thanks for the advice. My bf and I recently broke up. We didn’t have contact for about 2 weeks but eventually I contacted him and we’ve been communicating regularly and hanging out. He says he doesn’t want a relationship, but that’s where I’m getting confused. When we got back in contact, he told me he always wanted me in him life and I haven’t asked him to get back together. The only time I mentioned the old relationship was over a week ago and he stopped responding for a day. I asked him why he was not responding and he said didn’t want to talk about the past. Am I safe in saying he’s confused about his feelings for me?

  38. I wouldn’t say he’s confused about his feelings for you, more like he knows he still has strong feelings for you but is not sure if he wants a relationship with you.

    That’s a good thing and a bad thing at the same time.

    What’s bad about it is that he may have serious doubts about a relationship with you.

    What’s good about it is that 1) his feelings for you are still strong and 2) he is open to communication, and that means you can uncover what his concerns and doubts are, and try to show him that things can be better.

  39. Mikos says:

    I am in a similar situation, but kind of different. She pulls me in with promises and hope then disappears for 2 -3 days with no explanation. She says she doesn’t want to raise my hopes because right now she doesn’t know what she really wants. I am really starting to wonder whether this is even worth pursuing. Any thoughts would be appreciated.

  40. 1. I think that she’s honest when she says she doesn’t know what she wants and doesn’t want to raise your hopes.

    2. It’s also possible that when she says or does certain things, you misinterpret it to mean more than it really means.

    3. Her disappearing for 2 -3 days with no explanation is not good for any kind of relationship she may want in the future, but may be that’s the only way she knows how not get your hopes up.

    4. By being upfront with you, she’s leaving it up to you to decide whether to pursue the relationship any further — or not.

  41. Rhia says:

    Two weeks ago I was making much progress with my ex. We were even talking about trying the relationship again. Then I made one stupid mistake. I looked at his phone and saw a text from a woman he had been texting for sometime. I confronted him about it and we had a fight. Now he says he’s not sure about us. We broke up because he said I didn’t trust him. We still text each other but he is distant now. It was wrong to look at his phone but I would not have known about the other woman had I not. I’m beginning t think that he was stringing me along and now wants to get rid of me to date the other woman. Just so you know, we’re in our 50s.

  42. He’s distant because he just realized that nothing has changed. You still don’t trust him. May be you have good reason not to, but doing exactly what made him breakup with you in the first place doesn’t help.

    Ask yourself: If I think he’s stringing me along, then why am I still trying to get him back?

    Sometimes your issues can cloud your judgement and make you see things that aren’t there. But sometimes, there is really fire where there is smoke, especially if he’s done things in the past that have given you good reason not to trust him.

    In short, you are the only one who knows what’s really going on in your relationship, and the only one who is best positioned to know what’s best for you.

  43. Rhia says:

    It’s both my issues and he cheated on his ex with me. He says although it is not an excuse, he was unhappy for a very long time when I came along. He’d never do it to me, he’d rather end the relationship than hurt me like that. The woman he was texting was his friend’s ex asking for his help reconciling them. I confirmed it with his friend.

    I need to work on my insecurities. I was wondering if you could help me. I’m very encouraged by you advice and think that I can learn a lot from you. How do I go about setting up coaching with you?

  44. I would love to work with you, but personal work is not one of my strengths. Struggling relationships and getting your ex back… that’s what I’m good at.

    Best to be honest, right?… (:

    Read more on working with me…http://www.torontosnumber1datedoctor.com/about_IAS.html

  45. Bart says:

    My ex broke up with me because she felt the “spark” was gone. She also said she wasn’t happy with me anymore. I genuinely believe that she still loves me but her fear being hurt again is holding her back. What do I do to help with her fear?

  46. If you genuinely believe she still loves you, then work on igniting the “spark” again, instead of acting like it’s about her, not you. If someone says YOU are not turning me on anymore, its about YOU.

    You can get that “spark” back, but you have to work on it.

Please read our POLICY for asking your question, then ask a BRIEF question or share insight. Thanks, I appreciate YOU!!